One of the most common reasons people think training with positive reinforcement isn't reliable is: "The treats in your pocket will never compete with every distraction and trigger in the real world!"

It's an understandable concern. We've all seen, and perhaps tried, waving a carrot or bucket of feed under a horse's nose to lure them into a float (trailer), or to coax an escapee back into the paddock - and seen that fail about as often as it succeeds.

It all comes down to a huge misunderstanding about how positive reinforcement (R+) works. It's not the treat in your pocket competing with everything the horse might find distracting, tempting or worrying - it's the reinforcement history and the positive association (positive conditioned emotional response / CER+) the horse has developed to your cues as a *result* of all the treats you've previously given, strengthening and maintaining the behaviours you need.

That history is exponentially more powerful than the value of any particular treat you might offer in the moment. This is why positive reinforcement is not only used for pets and tricks (as is often claimed), but also to train animals doing a huge variety of important, serious and often life-saving work, who must do long sequences of trained behaviour, in highly distracting and sometimes frightening or dangerous environments, with little to no reinforcement until they've completed the whole task. R+ training has proven to be extremely reliable with dogs, birds, dolphins (in the open ocean), the Apopo landmine detection rats and various others. This really does work with horses too - the principles of learning apply to all animals.

Like any training, it has to be done properly to be as effective as possible. But that doesn't mean you need to be an amazingly skilled trainer with years of experience to start achieving brilliant results with your own animals. It means you need a solid foundation in the basic (most important!) knowledge and skills, and to get in there and actually practice and do the training.

Every single time something "hasn't worked" with my own animals, it's been down to me being a lazy trainer and not having actually DONE enough training. Not a failure of R+ itself.

There are many more times R+ has come through, and shocked even me with just how effective it is.

One of many times I discovered exactly how powerful force free, R+ training can be was the day I discovered four of my horses had escaped their paddock. I found them way down the road, munching away happily on an abundance of lush green grass.

They came to me as soon as I called them, thanks to recall training and practice training on grass.

I had no halters or lead ropes with me, and no decent treats. All I had was half a pocket of fairly boring pellets.

My preference would have been to have something higher value, and a lot of it. Not to lure them along, but to reinforce such amazing behaviour in a situation where they had so many temptations and so much freedom, and still chose to do as I asked.

All four, without hesitation, followed me away from the open paddock full of delicious grass and along the road. All for the occasional bland pellet, which I was very stingy with, trying to ensure I didn't run out. Not because they'd stop following if I did - but because it was important to reinforce actually going back into their paddock at the end.

Two of them walked along calmly, while the other two had some fun jumping up and down the banks at the side of the road, just like dogs enjoying an off lead walk. But they stayed with me and came to target my hand when I needed them to stick close while we went around a bend in the road.

This happened thanks to lots of practice "leading" - first with no equipment, and then with the halter and lead on but never used to apply pressure as negative reinforcement or positive punishment. For a R+ trained horse the behaviour should be the same and they should follow cues regardless of equipment, because the equipment isn't there or needed for control.

I do understand the naysayers. Many people have trouble with horses even using the aversive methods humans have been "perfecting" for centuries. How could force free training alone possibly be reliable and safe? The scientific evidence about how and why positive reinforcement works with all species, in combination with the real world experience of those of us who use it, shows that it absolutely does.

Written by Kate Shaw and the PPGA Equine Sub-Committee

Puberty for my young colt Dustin approached quickly – time to practise those cooperative care procedures, hoping my plan for what I would need was good!

Wearing of a headcollar was in place, but no cues for leading or turning had been introduced or transferred to the headcollar, so we were left with target leading to get from A to B. At the time this omission seemed to not matter, but it did cause a minor problem due to the effects of sedative.

My main focus to prepare had been training for the intravenous (IV) injection, and in my youngsters case, training to allow a non-me (and male!) human to approach and perform the IV routine.

The other behaviour I envisaged needing (and had started training) was ‘stationary head’ training, to incorporate head still while the catheter was placed and the two injections were administered –

I started off with my modified chin rest, really a jaw rest, my cupped left hand positioned under his jaw where a cavesson noseband would go, with no weight in my hand. Once this behaviour was progressing, I then added my other hand to the front of his face (or where a blaze would run) after my under jaw hand was in place. Pause, click, treat.

My main focus with this boy had been ‘polite treat taking’, as adolescent males can sometimes be mouthy, plus teaching an equine how to behave calmly around food is really a much needed foundation behaviour.

Dustin was also a big boy, and a little gumby as he was growing, so a lot of my training had been with him in “Protected Contact” but basically with him behind a barrier. This kept us both safe, me from the accidental head swing or foot tread contact, him from my bad timing!

During training there was hay and grass available, and I was using pellets that were part of his diet as his reinforcement. Criteria for reinforcement was head in straight forward, or neutral position. Regardless of where I was. Face forward, neutral, working toward waiting calmly.

Well it turns out I had done so much of this, that while the Vet was preparing his gear, he noticed how still Dustin was with his head over the gate, and said "he is so still we could almost inject him there” so we did! His ‘stationary head’ was so good he didn’t even notice the needle!

Here was our only problem, once sedated our target leading failed to be effective enough for quick positioning – we needed to turn him to stand in the shade of the tree for the General Anaesthetic. Half way had to be good enough!

Apart from my turning over-sight, the whole procedure was calm and stress free (for equine and Vet, if not for the owner worrying if her training had been sufficient!)

Dustin stood quietly for his injections, sat on his brisket once awake for his recovery (his friends were quietly eating hay in the next yard in sight), and got up quietly an hour later.

A good outcome; and a good introduction to positive reinforcement co-operative care for our local veterinarian.

Written By Vicki Conroy & the PPGA Equine Sub-Committee

Food is a primary reinforcer. By which I mean, it's something that horses require to survive. Other primary reinforcers are things like water and sleep.

While it would be rather unethical to use water or sleep as a reinforcer, food is a very valuable tool when working with your horse.

"But isn't that just bribery - I want my horse to work for ME"

No living animal is intrinsically motivated by a desire to please us. The most common alternative to using food and positive reinforcement is to use pressure, punishment and fear.

In horse training this is often referred to as pressure and release training. An example of this would be keeping tension on the lead rope until the horse walks forward, at which point you drop the tension and the horse gets relief. Great! She has learned to walk forwards.

Have you ever tried this with a horse and not gotten the expected response? You’re pulling forwards, you obviously want them to walk forwards, right?

Well, for a horse, it’s not always that obvious. Many horses will feel the pressure and pull back against it, looking for relief (and a quick exit from your company). What then? Hmm, maybe tapping a whip on their rump will help them get the message. Ah, that’s got it. Now they’re walking forwards. You just needed to put some weight on the lead rope (Negative Reinforcement) and a whip (This is getting close to being Positive Punishment).

Imagine someone had a solid grip on your arm until you did.. something?? But you don't know what. You don't speak the same language as this other person, and they're not giving you any clues as to what will get them to let go. The relief you might feel when the grip finally does ease, would also be accompanied by negative feelings towards that person, and probably a reluctance to keep being near them. (Why is my horse so hard to catch?!)

Along with that tension and negativity, the other main issue with using this tactic is that you as the trainer always need to be the scariest thing in the vicinity. You might have a great grip on them, but suddenly when an air horn goes off, their first instinct will be to evade that bigger and scarier noise. In this scenario, the horse is unlikely to look to you to help them. You're the pressure person, and they want safety.

When you start training with positive reinforcement, multiple things will occur.

You’ll begin to develop a reinforcement history that will aid you in future emergencies. Sometimes trainers refer to this as adding some coins into the ‘trust account’.

You’ll begin to develop a Positive Conditioned Emotional Response, shortened to +CER. By frequently engaging in an activity your horse enjoys (positive reinforcement training), YOU yourself become a sign that something good could be about to happen. This +CER is a result of Classical Conditioning, you’ve heard of Pavlov’s dogs?

Next time you take some carrots to the paddock, think about how you’re using them. Are you feeding them at random? Can you use them to reinforce a behaviour you like? Try leaving the whip at home and see what you can accomplish only using the primary reinforcer of food.

It's knowing how horses learn, and teaching them in a way that makes pressure and intimidation unnecessary - it’s not a bribe!

Written by Madi Holmes and the PPGA Equine Sub-Committee

When we think about horse welfare, we often focus on physical health—good nutrition, hoof care, and exercise. But true welfare goes beyond the physical. A horse that is physically healthy but mentally broken or struggling is not a happy horse. Fear, stress, and loneliness can be just as damaging as malnutrition or injury.

When we observe wild horses, we see them living in strong, stable herds—where they form deep bonds, communicate constantly, and rely on each other for safety and comfort. Our domesticated horses share these same instincts and needs. When we isolate them in stables or paddocks or constantly change their social groups, we disrupt their ability to feel secure and at ease.

Many of us in Australia rely on agistment for our horses. While full-time stabling is less common here than in other parts of the world, many agistment setups have limited options, often offering only individual paddocks. Even when horses are kept in group paddocks, there is often continual change, with herd members coming and going. This instability disrupts social bonds and can lead to stress, anxiety, and even difficulty adjusting to situations or changes in daily life.

Horses are playful, curious, and deeply social. They need to roll in the mud, scratch on a fence post, and play with their herd. These natural interactions are essential for their well-being. If living through Covid and lockdown taught us anything, it’s how detrimental isolation can be to mental health. Horses are no different! They need companionship, choice, and control over their social interactions to truly thrive.

Promoting Stable Herd Environments for Better Welfare

While many of us may be limited in what we can offer due to time, budget and/or agistment restrictions, we can still advocate for better living conditions:

✅ Choosing options that offer consistent herd environments rather than frequent social disruptions.

✅ Encouraging agistment providers to prioritise long-term herd stability over constantly shifting paddock groups.

✅ Supporting the idea that horses should have companionship, choice, and control over their social interactions whenever possible.

Why a Stable Herd Matters:

✔ Social Bonds & Emotional Security – A consistent herd structure allows horses to form deep relationships, reducing anxiety and stress.

✔ Reduced Stress & Anxiety – When horses don’t have to adjust to ever-changing paddock mates, they become more resilient in daily life.

✔ More Choice & Control – Allowing horses to choose who they interact with, where they rest, and how they move helps create happier, more confident animals.

✔ Safety & Comfort – A stable herd provides natural security, reducing fear and reactivity.

✔ Fewer Behavioural Issues – Without social frustration, horses are less likely to develop vices like cribbing, weaving, or fence-walking.

Providing species-appropriate living conditions should be a priority in how we care for our horses. By promoting stable herd environments, despite our limitations, we can improve their mental and emotional well-being.

Let’s give our horses the life they deserve—one filled with companionship, choice, and security. "

Welcome to the Pet Professional Guild Australia Blog page.

The PPG Australia is a membership organisation representing pet industry professionals who are committed to science-based, force-free training and pet care. We have pet trainers (dogs, cats, birds and equine), veterinary behaviourists, dog walkers, groomers, and even people involved in doggy day care.

We are an official branch of the Pet Professional Guild, a worldwide organisation committed to advocating, educating and encouraging improvements in companion animal welfare through the use of fear free techniques.

We look forward to providing regular tips, tricks and thought provoking articles to help you learn more about your animal’s behaviour and how we can help them learn and have enriching lives.

So, I hope you will join us on this blog as delve into different training topics on a regular basis.

First off, there will be a post by Maddi Holmes from our equine sub committee. Enjoy!

- Sarah Campbell, President